Showdown: Local Influencer Marketing vs. Display Advertising

Imagine scrolling through your social media feed and seeing your favourite influencer sharing a must-have gadget with a personal touch. Now picture that same gadget popping up as a display ad while you browse random websites. Which one makes you more likely to check it out?

As a savvy marketer or business owner, choosing the right strategy to capture your audience’s attention can make all the difference. Let’s dive into the fun battle between influencer marketing and display advertising, breaking down their channels, mediums, reach, targeting, campaign management, measurement, and pricing. Let the comparison games begin!

Channel

Where your marketing message gets noticed.

Influencer Marketing: Takes the spotlight on social media platforms where influencers with engaged followings share your brand story in an authentic and relatable way.

Display Advertising: Shows up as banner ads, sidebars, or pop-ups on various websites, aiming to catch your eye while you’re surfing the web.

InfluencerDisplay Ads
High engagementYN
Ads delivered within content your audience enjoysYN
Personal interaction with the audienceYN
Endorse by trusted people vs. self-promotionYN
Quick and easy campaign setupYY
Ability to target specific groups of peopleYY
Proof of performanceYY

Medium

The format in which your message is delivered.

Influencer Marketing: Uses engaging content like videos, images, and stories to captivate audiences on social media.

Display Advertising: Relies on eye-catching banner ads or pop-ups across websites, offering a visual but less engaging experience.

InfluencerDisplay Ads
Visual formatsYY
Video adsYN
Text adsYY
Content fits seamlessly into user experienceYN

Reach

How far and wide your message travels.

Influencer Marketing: Reaches a targeted audience through influencers who have a dedicated following that trusts their recommendations.

Display Advertising: Reaches a broader audience as ads appear on various websites, but can be less precise in targeting.

InfluencerDisplay Ads
Guaranteed audience reachYN
Consistent ad frequencyYY
Ability to reach middle and older generationsYY
Ability to consistently reach younger generationsYY
Ability to reach people without digital devicesNN

Targeting

How you reach your ideal audience.

Influencer Marketing: Offers pinpoint targeting based on interests, behaviors, and follower demographics to ensure your message lands with the right people.

Display Advertising: Uses general targeting based on browsing habits and website visits, which can be broader and less specific.

InfluencerDisplay Ads
Target specific interestsYY
Target based on behaviours and demographicsYY
Ads follow users across the webYY
Ads shown based on past website visitsYY

Campaign Management

The behind-the-scenes action.

Influencer Marketing: Allows for quick and flexible content creation with influencers who know what resonates with their audience.

Display Advertising: Involves setting up campaigns, designing ads, and placing them on various websites, which can be more rigid.

InfluencerDisplay Ads
Speedy content creationYY
Flexible ad formats and placementsYY
Ads that fit naturally into user experienceYN
Campaigns managed through ad platformsYY

Measurement

Tracking how well your campaign performs.

 
 

Influencer Marketing: Provides detailed insights into engagement, reach, and conversions with real-time data and analytics.

Display Advertising: Offers performance metrics like impressions and clicks, but may lack depth in understanding user engagement.

InfluencerDisplay Ads
Real-time data and optimization ability YN
Detailed engagement trackingYN
Ability to track how many consumers have seen your adsYY
Ability to track ad comments, shares, and reactionsYN
Measure return on investmentYY

Pricing

Cost considerations.

Influencer Marketing: Offers scalable pricing based on influencer reach and engagement, often providing better value for targeted campaigns.

Display Advertising: Costs can vary based on ad placements and formats, with expenses dependent on the website and audience size.

InfluencerDisplay Ads
Affordable ratesYY

Conclusion

While display advertising still has its place in the marketing mix, influencer marketing offers a dynamic, engaging, and targeted approach that connects with audiences on a more personal level. If you’re aiming to make a memorable impact and engage with consumers authentically, influencer marketing might just be your secret weapon.

Ready to explore how influencer marketing can spice up your brand’s presence? Get in touch to learn more about what local influencer marketing can do for your business.

Let's get started.